![]()
![]()
SURPRISING STRENGTH
Strength training was once just for people who wanted a great body. Now, it is for people who want a great life.
Mature Outlook, August 2000 © by Gary Legwold
An old Welsh proverb goes, "Three things give hardy strength: sleeping on hairy mattresses, breathing cold air, and eating dry food."
None of these options looks very appealing. But then, gaining hardy strength has never really appealed to many of us. We don't want big muscles, necessarily, and we already get plenty of exercise, thank you, with walking, biking, swimming, or doing other aerobic activities. So why bother with strength training?
Ask Evelyn Crim. Crim, 75, was a bit skeptical when she signed up for a golf strength training course with her husband, George. "I thought this was crazy," she recalls. "I couldn't imagine older people doing strength training. Also, it was intimidating to me because it was something that men did. Well, it was a turning point in my life."
Crim's arthritic hands began to feel better, her muscles felt good, she lost weight and gained energy, and she felt a "good tired" when class was done. She had had a complete knee replacement, making walking difficult. However, with strength training, she could rest the knee and still exercise the hips, thighs, and rest of the body. Socially, the class was great. Evelyn liked the friends she met and the time spent with George. "I enjoyed it thoroughly," says Crim, of Wollaston, Mass. "I felt like I lost 10 years from my age."
Then in the spring of 1999, Evelyn lost George. His death hit her hard. She quit the class and withdrew. After a while, the instructor called, concerned that she wasn't getting out of the house. She decided to go back, knowing that exercise would help her own heart condition and her outlook.
"I was getting very depressed after George died," she says. "The class and the people there motivated me to take care of myself. I even did my own decorating and lights last Christmas. That strength training class has been a big plus in my life."
The Benefits of Buffing Up
Like Crim, many people who could never imagine themselves pumping iron later in life are doing just that. Strength training, which was once done by a small group of Charles Atlas types, has gone mainstream. And exercise experts, who once put strength training down the list of recommended activities for older people, are now putting it at the top.
"Absolutely, strength training is the most important component of a fitness program for older people," says Wayne Westcott, Ph.D., Fitness Research Director at the South Shore YMCA in Quincy, Mass.
Westcott says stretching exercises are necessary to remain limber as we age. And walking and aerobic activities are a must for the cardiovascular system. But, as Ball State University's David Pearson, Ph.D., says, "it won't do you any good to have a good heart and good lungs to climb stairs, for example, if you do not have good muscles to do so."
"Quite honestly," says Westcott, "most of us in this age group are not that concerned about running and swimming fast. We are more concerned with going up stairs, lifting grandchildren and groceries, doing house and yard work—those kinds of activities. So, our first concern should be to get the musculoskeletal system in shape."
Getting the muscles in shape is only one benefit of strength training. Westcott can wear you out with others, including:
- Avoiding muscle loss. Typically, men lose 5 pounds per decade in muscle mass after middle age. Women lose 6.5 pounds in muscle mass through menopause, and then 10 pounds per decade after that. Running alone won't prevent that loss. One study showed that 45-year-old runners who trained hard enough over 10 years to maintain their aerobic conditioning still lost 5 pounds of muscle mass.
- Avoiding decreases in resting metabolic rate (RMR) and increases in body fat. Typically, the decrease in RMR parallels the decrease in muscle mass—about 5 percent per decade after age 50. This drop means a slowdown in your metabolic "engine," fewer calories burned, and a gradual increase in body fat. This gradual fat increase, called creeping obesity, is about 15 pounds per decade.
- Increasing muscle mass and RMR, and decreasing fat. Westcott conducted a study of 1,132 older people who did eight weeks of strength training for 20- to 25-minutes daily two to three times a week. They added an average three pounds of muscle, raised their RMR 7 percent, and lost four pounds of fat.
- Avoiding loss—and perhaps making gains—in bone mineral density. This reduces the risk of osteoporosis.
- Enhancing glucose metabolism, by almost 25 percent in one study. This may reduce the risk of adult onset diabetes.
- Increasing gastrointestinal transit speed (GTS). One three-month study showed that strength training increased GTS 56 percent. Slow GTS correlates highly with colon cancer.
- Decreasing resting blood pressure. Blood pressure goes up while lifting, but only momentarily. Westcott says one study showed a 3-4 mm Hg drop in resting systolic blood pressure among older people who did strength training.
- Decreasing cholesterol levels while increasing the level of HDL (the good) cholesterol.
- Increasing low back muscle strength. A University of Florida strength training program was 80 percent successful in eliminating or alleviating low back pain.
- Decreasing arthritis pain and increasing joint range of motion and functionality.
- Improving balance. Strong muscles help you maintain balance and catch yourself before falling. This reduces your risk of falls and broken bones.
- Decreasing depression. A Harvard study showed that of the 16 clinically depressed older people who did a strength-training program, 14 no longer met the criteria for clinical depression after the 12-week program.
Getting Started
OK, seeing these benefits has swayed you to give strength training a try. Now what?
First, receive medical clearance for strength training from your doctor. He or she can explain the importance of regular breathing throughout strength training exercises. According to the University of Maryland's Ben Hurley, Ph.D., many people hold their breath when they lift, causing a Valsalva maneuver in blood vessels. This maneuver, which you can minimize with proper breathing technique, can elevate blood pressure to dangerous levels.
Second, "don't go to a discount store, buy some weights, and go home and start lifting," says Pearson. Pearson and most other experts do not advise free weights for older people, unless they use light dumbbells. Experts recommend machines, which are safer, designed so you use proper technique, and usually supervised at fitness centers.
Third, be an informed consumer. Do this by:
- Contacting the American College of Sports Medicine in Indianapolis (317-637-9200) and the National Strength and Conditioning Association in Colorado Springs (719-632-6722) for advice on starting strength training programs.
- Read about strength training. There are many books, including Westcott's Strength Training Past 50 (Human Kinetics, Champaign, IL 1-800-747-4457).
- Check out classes at your local YMCA, YWCA, university, and fitness centers. Go on site and talk with instructors about their philosophy and qualifications.
- If you join a fitness center, says Pearson, don't sign a long-term contract that allows for an automatic deduction of fees from your bank account. You want make sure you can end membership without hassle and loss of money.
Fourth, find a buddy. To do strength training with a spouse or friend increases your chances of ongoing success and shared enjoyment.
Good Muscles, Good Lifestyle
Joseph Cleggett, 55, has a pretty good buddy his wife, Kathy. "This strength training class is great for us," says Cleggett of Braintree, Mass. "It forces us to take a break from our busy schedules and have 1 1/2 to 2 hours together."
Joseph was as strong as an ox as a college athlete, but then "I let my body go," he says. Job pressures kept him at the office and away from exercise. Years passed, and then he lost a 49-year-old friend to a heart attack. Joseph himself developed a heart condition and, with his daughter Erin's prodding and his doctors OK, enrolled with Kathy in a strength-training class at the YMCA.
In order to fit exercise into his schedule, he gets up earlier, goes to work later, and watches less TV. But the changes are worth it. "I had forgotten how good it feels to exercise," he says. "I like to work with my body, and do things like mow the lawn, weed flowers, dig in the dirt, get sweaty. It's a release of stress and frustrations, I guess. I like to get tired and then come in and rest. Strength training helps me maintain myself physically. The longer I can use my muscles like this, the longer I will enjoy life."
Strength Training Exercises (sidebar)
A strength training program is personal. One program does not fit all because each of us has different goals and physical limitations. That said, here are some general guidelines for strength training from Wayne Westcott, Ph.D., Fitness Research Director at the South Shore YMCA in Quincy, Mass.:
Training Exercises: Work the major muscle groups (Tables 1 and 2). If training time is limited, do these three multiple-muscle exercises: leg press (quadriceps and hamstrings), bench press (chest, shoulders, arms) and rowing (back and arms).
Training Frequency: Work out two to three times a week. If training time is limited, Westcott says twice a week produces almost as many gains as three times a week.
Training Sets: Do 8-12 repetitions of each exercise per set, and do 1-3 sets. If training time is limited, do one set and receive almost as many benefits as doing three, says Westcott. Work at 60 to 90 percent of maximum resistance. When in doubt, go light to avoid injury. Breathe continuously while lifting to avoid unnecessary blood pressure rises. Use good posture and technique. Add about 5 percent in resistance when you can do 12 reps confidently and under control.
Table 1: Standard Machine and Free-Weight Exercises for the Major Muscles
Major Muscle Group
Machine Exercise
Free-Weight Exercise
Quadriceps (front thigh)
Leg Extension
Dumbbell Squat
Hamstrings (back thigh)
Leg Curl
Dumbbell Squat
Quads, Hamstrings, Gluteals (butt)
Leg Press
Dumbbell Squat
Pectoralis Major (chest)
Chest Cross
Dumbbell Bench Press
Latissimus Dorsi (upper back)
Pullover
Dumbbell Bent Row
Deltoids (shoulders)
Lateral Raise
Dumbbell Lateral Raise
Biceps (front arm)
Biceps Curl
Dumbbell Curl
Triceps (back arm)
Triceps Extension
Dumbbell Overhead Extension
Erector Spinae (low back)
Low Back Extension
Bodyweight Back Extension
Rectus Abdominis (tummy)
Abdominal Curl
Bodyweight Trunk Curl
Neck Flexors/Extensors
Four-Way Neck
Table 2: Strength-Training Circuit for Functional Musculoskeletal Development
Machine Exercise
Major Muscles
Functional Application
Leg Press
Quadriceps
Standing up, walking, climbing stairs
Triceps Press
Triceps (back arm), Pectoralis Major (chest)
Arm assisting when standing up and climbing stairs (using railing)
Low Back
Erector Spinae (low back)
Maintaining erect posture in low torso and avoiding slouched-back positions
Compound Row
A variety of back muscles, biceps (front arm)
Maintaining erect posture in upper torso and avoiding hunched-shoulder positions
4-Way Neck
Neck Flexors, Neck Extensors
Maintaining erect posture in neck area and avoiding drooped-head positions
You Go Girl! (sidebar)
Many women frown at the thought of strength training. Kathy Cleggett, 53, once did. She grew up when few, if any, female high school sports existed, and physical activity was kind of a guy thing.
"I didn't get any exercise before I signed up for a strength training class," she says. "I thought this kind of class was where strong people went to get stronger. I never saw myself as strong, and I was intimidated."
So, now that she has gone through a few classes, would she recommend strength training to other women? "I would, now that I know I can do it and I belong," says Cleggett, from Braintree, Mass.
![]()
Gary Legwold
glegwold@lutefisk.com
(612) 926-1877"Ideas Need Words"
© Copyright 2004 Gary Legwold and Conrad Henry Press. All rights reserved.